Five Forgotten Superstars of American Sport

By Amelia Walker Senior Content Writer Updated: 01 April 2024

Amelia Walker Senior Content Writer

Amelia Walker is a Senior Content Writer at Betting.US. She has a law degree and deep knowledge of the gambling laws in the United States. Her mission is to keep players informed about responsible gambling, while her passion for sports helps her create useful guides. Amelia has over a decade of experience in betting, which has positioned her as a trusted voice among our readers.

See Full Bio

Twitter X

American Sport’s Forgotten Superstars

• Forgotten Athletes: A Look Back
• Stories of a Forgotten Sports Hero
• Shaun Alexander’s Lost Legacy
• Adrian Dantley: Basketball’s Forgotten Star
• Ron Francis: Hockey’s Hidden Gem
• Priest Holmes: An NFL Memory
• Bob McAdoo: The NBA’s Lost Icon
• Frequently Asked Questions

Today’s blog on the top five forgotten athletes will take you on a journey through the archives of sports history. In this blog, we revisit the careers of athletes who shook the world with their talent but have since slipped from the public eye.

From the NFL to the NBA, these forgotten sports superstars all – once – left their mark on their respective games, only to fade into the shadows. Join us as we uncover the legacies of Shaun Alexander, Adrian Dantley, Ron Francis, Priest Holmes, and Bob McAdoo!

Forgotten Athletes: A Look Back

Some of the forgotten athletes we will cover today may surprise you. However, the reality is, while some may remember them – for the most part, their legacies have not been carried on like we’d have expected.

While our site usually focuses on guides – for example, how to bet on live boxing – we also like to do deep dives into sports history, and this is one such piece! So, without waiting any longer, let’s get stuck in. Do you have a forgotten sports hero?

Stories of a Forgotten Sports Hero

The forgotten sports hero names we’ll cover today were once remarkably talented athletes whose stories have since faded from memory. Among them, Shaun Alexander stands out. His journey from a college sensation to an NFL superstar, culminating in the 2005 MVP award, is a story about never giving up. Alexander’s record-breaking 27 touchdowns in a single season is enough on its own – yet despite such incredible achievements, his name is rarely mentioned!

Or what about Adrian Dantley? He was a scoring machine, leading the league in points per game in two seasons. But he was always overshadowed by flashier players – which is a shame because, pound for pound, he was one of the most prolific scorers ever.

And you can’t forget about Ron Francis when talking about old-school hockey. Wayne Gretzky may have made all the headlines, but Francis ranks among the NHL’s best in career assists. He had this incredible on-ice vision and could thread a pass through the tightest spaces. Unfortunately, he flew under the radar playing for Hartford and Pittsburgh.

The list of forgotten superstars goes on, including overlooked talents like Priest Holmes, who was unstoppable during his prime years in Kansas City, and Bob McAdoo, who won an MVP but has since rarely been mentioned in basketball discussions. Remember, while we love to glorify the biggest superstars, so many quiet legends risk being forgotten – which is why this blog aims to highlight a few names we hope to bring out of the dark!

Shaun Alexander’s Lost Legacy

In retrospect, Shaun Alexander’s remarkable yet short legacy in the NFL warrants a closer look. Following a successful college career with Alabama, Alexander entered the NFL burdened with high expectations. However, he quickly shut down any doubts with the Seattle Seahawks, developing a reputation as one of football’s most feared running backs.

Alexander’s incredible 2005 campaign showcased the absolute height of his abilities. In an insane effort, he rushed for a league-leading 1,880 yards while setting a new NFL record with 27 touchdowns in a single season – a record that cemented his status as the game’s most unstoppable rusher at the time! He ended up enjoying MVP honors, too.

However, Alexander’s stardom was short-lived. A string of injuries put a dampener on his once-defining abilities, and with diminished speed and power, he struggled to rediscover his best form in later years with the Seahawks and Redskins. By the end of the 2007 season, Alexander’s playing days were sadly cut short, forcing one of the NFL’s most successful runners to the back of the mind for most.

While LT, Adrian Peterson, and others still dominate running back memories, Alexander’s fleeting yet exceptional legacy deserves its place in history. At his peak, few could match his touchdown and big-play abilities, combined with his MVP-winning streak.

Adrian Dantley: Basketball’s Forgotten Star

Though rarely mentioned today, Dantley’s scoring abilities during his 1980s heyday compare favorably even to more skilled, well-known athletes competing today. His abilities near the rim, mid-range marksmanship, and foul-drawing skills made him impossible to contain.

The stats underline Dantley’s abilities: he led the league in scoring twice while averaging over 24 points per game over six years. Such consistency of output, through an array of moves and shot types, underlines his versatility and reliability as a scorer. Even as defenses intensified efforts to try to stop him, he managed to outsmart opponents.

However, Dantley was no one-dimensional shooter either. He sacrificed personal stats for team success, adapting his game to evolving situations. Whether assuming primary scoring duties or setting up others, Dantley’s commitment to his team was unquestioned. However, this admirable selflessness may have left the public unable to see his natural talent.

In our opinion, he was a brilliant player and one of the best past sports star names we’re covering today. Despite being inducted into the Hall of Fame back in 2008, he rarely received the attention we feel he should. Below, we will share some of Dantley’s stats:

Ron Francis: Hockey’s Hidden Gem

Ron Francis’ career in the NHL is a remarkable journey of consistency, skill, and quiet leadership. Often overlooked in discussions about hockey legends, Francis built a legacy that deserves far more recognition than it typically receives. His career spanned over two decades, during which he established himself as one of the greatest centers the game has ever seen.

Francis’ abilities lay in his extraordinary playmaking ability. He had an uncanny knack for reading the game, understanding where players would be, and delivering pinpoint passes that led to scoring opportunities. His vision on the ice was second to none, making him a formidable presence and a master at setting goals. His standing as the fifth all-time leader in NHL assists reflects this skill set.

Beyond his playmaking skills, Francis was also a reliable scorer. He amassed over 1,700 points throughout his career. Yet, despite these impressive numbers, Francis often flew under the radar, perhaps due to his unassuming personality and the era in which he played, in which more flashy, well-known players dominated.

Priest Holmes: An NFL Memory

Though injuries made his career short-lived, Priest Holmes delivered a four-year NFL masterclass announcing his arrival as an elite running back. Long considered an afterthought, Holmes leveraged his sudden opportunity with Kansas City into spectacular heights most could only dream of. At his peak, few tailbacks could match Holmes on the field.

Undoubtedly, 2001 marked Holmes’s most impressive season. Given a chance to headline the Chiefs’ offense, he immediately led the NFL in rushing behind an eye-popping 6.9 yards per attempt. This initial success was no fluke, as he also showed similar talent in subsequent seasons.

Naturally, being so important to Kansas City’s success, Holmes attracted endless attention from opponents. Yet no defensive scheme or strategy slowed his relentless production and habit of getting into the end zone. His 26 touchdowns in 2003 was an NFL record, which makes it so surprising that he faded abruptly away in 2004.

Bob McAdoo: The NBA’s Lost Icon

Bob McAdoo’s NBA career is a story of incredible talent, adaptability, and a long-lasting impact on the game of basketball. As one of the top players of the 1970s, McAdoo’s contributions to the sport were groundbreaking and awe-inspiring. His journey from a young, talented scorer to an NBA champion showcases his incredible career filled with individual ability and solid teamwork.

McAdoo burst onto the NBA scene with the Buffalo Braves (now the Los Angeles Clippers), immediately establishing himself as a top scorer. He won the NBA scoring title three consecutive times, proving his offensive abilities. However, McAdoo was not just a scorer; he was a complete player. His ability to rebound, block shots, and even assist his teammates made him a threat in all areas on the court.

However, McAdoo’s career was also characterized by frequent team changes, often leading to him slipping under the radar in the eyes of the general public. Despite his MVP award in 1975, McAdoo’s constant movement between teams meant he never had a stable platform to solidify his legacy with a single franchise. This hectic career path, despite showing his adaptability to the game, eventually led to him becoming one of the forgotten sports superstars.