Five of American Sport’s Shortest Coaching Tenures

By Amelia Walker Senior Content Writer Updated: 25 July 2024

Amelia Walker Senior Content Writer

Amelia Walker is a Senior Content Writer at Betting.US. She has a law degree and deep knowledge of the gambling laws in the United States. Her mission is to keep players informed about responsible gambling, while her passion for sports helps her create useful guides. Amelia has over a decade of experience in betting, which has positioned her as a trusted voice among our readers.

See Full Bio

Twitter X

American Sport’s Shortest Coaching Tenures

• Shortest Head Coach Tenure
• Shortest NFL Coaching Tenures
• Bill Belichick’s One-Day Stint
• George Allen’s Preseason Exile
• Pete McCulley’s Turbulent Nine
• Adrian Griffin’s Bucks Departure
• Jerry Tarkanian’s Spurs Struggle

The world of professional sports is filled with tales of nail-biting wins, bitter defeats, and legendary athletes (and coaches) who have left an undeniable mark on their respective games. However, not every coach’s journey is a long and successful one.

In fact, some coaching tenures are so brief, they barely even have time to familiarize themselves with players and fans! In today’s blog post, we’ll take a closer look at some of the shortest head coaching tenures in the history of American professional sports.

Shortest Head Coach Tenure

When it comes to the shortest head coach tenure in American professional sports, the NFL, NBA, and NHL have all had their fair share of brief stints. In the NFL, Bill Belichick’s one-day tenure with the New York Jets in 2000 stands out as a bizarre and memorable moment in league history.

The NBA has seen its own share of short-lived coaching tenures, too, with Jerry Tarkanian’s 20-game stint with the San Antonio Spurs in 1992 being the shortest in league history. The NHL, meanwhile, has had several coaches last less than a full season, with some of the shortest NHL coaching tenures lasting less than a season!

Remember, as fans, it’s easy to get caught up in the wins and losses and to forget about the human element of coaching. The shortest coaching tenures that we’ll be looking at today should act as a reminder that every time a coach is fired, there are real people involved. Coaches have families, emotions, and dreams too – it’s not just the players – and while the business of professional sports can be unforgiving, it’s important to remember that there are real people involved.

Whether you want to find out about the shortest NFL coaching tenures or the shortest NBA coaching tenures – this blog aims to show you what’s what! Plus, if you’re looking for the sportsbooks with NBA odds don’t forget to check out our recommended sportsbooks, all of which offer loads of NBA betting markets.

Shortest NFL Coaching Tenures

The NFL is a high-pressure environment where coaches are expected to deliver results quickly. When a team struggles, the head coach is often the first to take the blame. As a result, the NFL has seen its fair share of brief coaching tenures over the years.

One of the most notable examples of the shortest NFL coaching tenures is Pete McCulley’s nine-game stint with the San Francisco 49ers in 1978. McCulley, who had never been a head coach at any level before, was tasked with turning around a struggling 49ers team. However, he was fired after just nine games, posting a 1-8 record. The 49ers would go on to commit a staggering 63 turnovers that season, the second-most in NFL history!

Another of the shortest NFL coaching tenures belongs to George Allen, who was fired by the Los Angeles Rams in 1978 after just two preseason games.

Allen, a Hall of Famer who had never had a losing season as a head coach, was let go by owner Carroll Rosenbloom after two underwhelming performances. He was replaced by defensive coordinator Ray Malavasi, who led the Rams to a 12-4 record that season.

Of course, it should come as no surprise to learn that in a sport as competitive as the NFL, money and performance talk – and if a team is slipping even a bit, owners and shareholders will be looking to make changes. Unfortunately, this is just one of the parts of being a coach; there are no guarantees, and even if you do your best, there’s no guarantee the owners will be happy with the results you produce!

We’re now going to take a closer look at five coaches who had some of the shortest coaching tenures in US sports history.

Bill Belichick’s One-Day Stint

Perhaps the most bizarre and memorable short-lived coaching tenure in NFL history belongs to Bill Belichick and his one-day stint as head coach of the New York Jets in 2000. Belichick, who had been the Jets’ highly-touted defensive coordinator, was set to succeed Hall of Famer Bill Parcells as head coach when Parcells stepped down in 1999.

However, during his introductory press conference, Belichick stunned the football world by announcing his resignation. The Jets and Commissioner Paul Tagliabue agreed that Belichick was still under contract, but the New England Patriots ultimately traded a first-round draft pick to acquire him as their new head coach.

Belichick’s decision to leave the Jets after just one day sent shockwaves through the NFL. Many questioned his loyalty and character, while others saw it as a smart business move. Regardless of what you think, there’s no denying that Belichick’s one-day tenure with the Jets is one of the most unusual chapters in NFL history – and definitely the shortest head coach tenure in the sport’s history!

George Allen’s Preseason Exile

George Allen is one of the most successful coaches in NFL history, with a career record of 118-54-5 over 12 seasons. He never had a losing season as a head coach and led the Washington Redskins to a Super Bowl appearance in 1972. However, his second stint with the Los Angeles Rams in 1978 was far less successful – as you’ll see below.

Allen had previously coached the Rams from 1966 to 1970, leading them to two playoff appearances. When he returned to the team in 1978, expectations were high. However, after just two underwhelming preseason games, owner Carroll Rosenbloom made the shocking decision to fire Allen.

The move was met with widespread criticism and disbelief. Many felt that Allen deserved more time to implement his system and get the team on track. However, Rosenbloom was apparently unimpressed with the team’s performance in the preseason and felt that a change was necessary.

Defensive coordinator Ray Malavasi was named as the new head coach and led the Rams to a 12-4 record and a playoff berth that season. While Malavasi deserves credit for his success, many still wonder what might have been had Allen been given more time to work his magic in Los Angeles!

Pete McCulley’s Turbulent Nine

Pete McCulley’s nine-game tenure as head coach of the San Francisco 49ers in 1978 is a prime example of how quickly things can go wrong for a new coach in the NFL. McCulley had been an assistant coach in the league for several years but had never been a head coach at any level of football.

When the 49ers hired him to replace Ken Meyer, who had been fired after a 5-9 season in 1977, they hoped that McCulley could turn things around quickly. To improve the team’s offense, they traded five draft picks, including a first-rounder, to the Buffalo Bills for Hall of Fame running back O.J. Simpson.

However, things quickly went south for McCulley and the 49ers. The team lost its first eight games under McCulley, and the offense struggled a lot. Simpson, who was nearing the end of his career, was pretty ineffective, and the team committed a massive number of turnovers – to the dismay of fans.

After a 1-8 start, the 49ers fired McCulley and replaced him with Fred O’Connor. The team would go on to finish the season with a 2-14 record, committing a total of 63 turnovers, which remains the second-most in history behind only the 1961 Denver Broncos.

McCulley’s brief and rocky tenure with the 49ers shows exactly how difficult it can be for a new coach to find success in the NFL, especially when tasked with turning around a struggling team! Here are some details of McCulley’s brief stint with the 49ers:

Adrian Griffin’s Bucks Departure

Moving over to the NBA, one of the more recent examples of a short-lived coaching tenure is that of Adrian Griffin with the Milwaukee Bucks. Griffin, who had previously served as an assistant coach for several teams, including the Chicago Bulls, Orlando Magic, Oklahoma City Thunder, and Toronto Raptors, was hired as the Bucks’ head coach in June 2023.

However, just 233 days and 43 games later, Griffin was fired by the Bucks. Surprisingly, the team’s record was not the main reason for his dismissal. At the time of his firing, the Bucks had a 30-13 record, which was among the best in the league.

Instead, it was Griffin’s coaching style, the team’s poor defensive performance, and the fact that, according to some, he’d failed to gel with the players. Despite having a talented roster led by Giannis Antetokounmpo and Khris Middleton, the Bucks struggled defensively under Griffin, ranking 20th in the league in defensive rating.

Reports also surfaced of tension between Griffin and some players, with some questioning his ability to connect with and motivate them. In the end, the Bucks decided that a change was necessary, and Griffin was let go less than a year after being hired.

Griffin’s 43-game tenure is tied for the third shortest in NBA history, matching that of Rudy Tomjanovich with the Los Angeles Lakers in 2004-05. While the circumstances of their departures were different, it shows exactly how competitive the NBA can be – and now, you can see why the shortest NBA coaching tenures are a bit more common than you may think!

Jerry Tarkanian’s Spurs Struggle

Jerry Tarkanian is a legendary figure in college basketball, having led the UNLV Runnin’ Rebels to four Final Four appearances and a national championship in 1990. However, his brief entry into the NBA with the San Antonio Spurs in 1992 was far less successful.

Tarkanian was hired by the Spurs in April 1992, after a successful college coaching career that included a 509-105 record at UNLV. However, his transition to the NBA was anything but smooth. His time with the Spurs lasted just 20 games, the shortest of any coach in NBA history. During that stretch, the team went 9-11, and there were reports of tension between Tarkanian and the team’s players and management.

One of the primary issues was Tarkanian’s disagreement with Spurs owner Red McCombs over the need for a point guard. The team had lost Rod Strickland to free agency in the offseason, leaving a significant hole in the backcourt. Tarkanian reportedly wanted the team to acquire a new point guard, but McCombs was hesitant to do so – and didn’t.

After just 20 games, the Spurs decided to make a change, firing Tarkanian and replacing him with John Lucas. The team would go on to finish the season with a 49-33 record under Lucas, making the playoffs as the fifth seed in the Western Conference.

Tarkanian’s brief and unsuccessful tenure with the Spurs remains one of the more interesting parts of NBA coaching history. While his accomplishments at the college level are considered to be some of the best ever, his struggles in San Antonio show that just because a coach has succeeded in one league – or area – it doesn’t mean that they’ll necessarily succeed in another.